InfoDome - Common Pitfalls to Library Research to Infodome homepage
Research
About Us Services Computing Information For

Common Pitfalls to Library Research

Common Pitfalls to Library Research

An entire class looking for one piece of information or researching the same specific topic; especially difficult when printed materials are involved. Students required to use printed materials the library does not own (or does own, but not in sufficient quantity), or online sources they are not licensed to access.

Students working from incomplete or incorrect information. Please verify the information is correct and current and any jargon is explained shortly before handing out the assignment. Feel free to ask a librarian to help with this verification process.

Provide assignments in a printed/printable version. By the time the students requests assistance at the reference desk, they are frequently asking for something completely different!

Students assigned excessively vague or general topics, e.g., "women in South America," without guidance on narrowing a topic.

Students given obscure trivia questions and told to find the answers.

Students not willing to use online periodical indexes or online journals since they were told not to use the Internet. Please clarify with students that a database is not the same thing the Internet or the Web.

Students working on a library assignment having no relation to the course.

Teaching faculty and TA's not attending or remaining at the library session. Students feel the information less useful or necessary when faculty do not attend the sessions. In fact, we frequently hear the teaching faculty comment that they also learned something during these sessions!

Tips for Effective Research Assignments

The ability to find, evaluate, and use information is essential for students. However, the skills required to find the best information, and in the most efficient manner, must be taught and practiced repeatedly. Through class assignments, teaching faculty have the power to influence students¹ development as seekers and users of information. Many students are not Œinformation literate¹ when they arrive at university or begin work in a new subject area. They may not understand how to locate relevant information, or how to think critically about the information sources they encounter. Their coursework is frequently their sole opportunity to learn the difference between Œsurfing the Net¹ and substantive research.

A well-designed library or research assignment can teach students valuable research skills and improve the quality of their papers. Unfortunately, these same assignments also have the potential to confuse and frustrate students, leading to a poorly-written product. The term/research paper has been the most commonly used method of evaluating whether or not students can successfully apply information seeking skills - but there are other ways.

A few suggestions to keep in mind when developing assignments requiring research:

1. Consult with a Reference Librarian. Librarians will work with you to design an appropriate assignment that will achieve your course goals/objectives.

2. Notify the Librarians. Sending a copy of the assignment to your subject librarian or use the upcoming online Assignment Alert form before giving it to your students will ensure the library staff is ready to help your students when needed.

3. Assume minimal library knowledge. Although many students may be familiar with - or mistakenly feel they are familiar with - using some library tools, few really understand the intricacies of controlled vocabulary or keyword searching, locating items in our library, and many have never used research journals. Frequently students need to be reminded that experts write journal articles, their audience is other experts, and they expect a level of knowledge about the topic. Initially reading reference books, textbooks, and subject-specific encyclopedias creates a foundation of knowledge on this topic and prepares them to search for articles more effectively.

4. Explain the assignment clearly, preferably in writing. Give students a clear idea of what the assignment involves by creating learning objectives and making them clear to students. This helps students focus on the research-related skills they should learn as a result of the assignment. Suggest types and quantities of sources to be used. Provide complete, accurate (current) citations for specific works.

5. Ensure the library still holds the needed information. Students get extremely frustrated looking for non-existent or checked out resources. Pre-research topics and sources to ensure adequate information is available on a topic or in the format you require before assigning it. Also check that the book is in the same location in the library; material regularly is moved from reference areas to the stacks. Print and electronic course reserves are available for materials needed by many students. Please send an advance copy of the assignment and its due date to your subject librarian or the Library Instruction Coordinator or use the upcoming online Assignment Alert form.

6. Avoid the mob scene. Dozens of students using a single book or article, or looking for the same information frequently leads to misplacement, loss, or mutilation of materials. Provide a variety of topics and sources. Use the print and electronic course reserves as needed.

7. Avoid scavenger hunts or timed exercises. Searching for obscure facts frustrates students, can cause chaos in the library stacks, and teaches students little about research. If planning a library exercise, please talk to a librarian subject specialist about designing one appropriate to the class.

8. Consider alternative designs for the assignments. Samples of alternatives to the research paper can be found at http://libweb.sdsu.edu/faculty/altassign.html.

9. Teach research strategy/process when appropriate. Research strategies may seem obvious to experienced researchers but are frequently unknown to students. Breaking down the assignment into steps of the research process will help them accomplish your stated objectives. Students benefit from opportunities to reflect on their research strategies and think critically about what they are doing. Invite a librarian to review strategies for the assignment with the class and discuss appropriate tools or types of materials. Help students develop specific, well-defined research topics.

10. Encourage students to talk to a librarian at the reference desk when they have questions. Students frequently need to be encouraged to approach a librarian. They sometimes feel they should know the information already or that they are disturbing the library staff. Students need to realize library research is part of the new knowledge and skill set they learn and continue to foster at university.

11. Visit the library often. Familiarize yourself with the changes, improvements and new materials that appear regularly. A librarian is very willing to speak with you about services, resources, database searching, etc.

12. Electronic journals and periodical indexes are not 'The Internet.' Students are frequently not willing to use online periodical databases or electronic journals since they were told not to use the Internet. Please clarify that a database or electronic journal to which the Library subscribes is not the same as searching the World Wide Web. We simply use the Internet as an interface to access this information. With sufficient lead time, librarians can provide presentations and written materials geared specifically to your course and assignment, as well as general orientations for more inexperienced students. PLEASE ASK!

(Adapted from Guidelines for Effective Library Assignments from Library Instruction, University of Oregon Library System. http://libweb.uoregon.edu/instruct/assignments.html Last viewed: 8/20/00.)


Search This Site Send Feedback

This page http://infodome.sdsu.edu/about/depts/instruction/pitfalls.shtml is maintained by Natalie Pastor. Please use our Feedback Form for your questions, comments, and suggestions.

File saved 11/01/01 13:40 PST